By George & Josh Bate

WARNING: The following contains spoilers for Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 Episode 4: “Young Blood”
After a trio of unfocused episodes juggling a few too many plot threads and characters, Dexter: Resurrection’s sophomore season returns for a routine outing of the beloved series that shows promise for the story ahead in its final moments.
The central storyline driving “Young Blood” is Dexter’s hunt for the Jaw Splitter, a serial killer who targeted young men and removed their jaws while they were still alive. Jaw Splitter is the last killer from Prater’s Boogeyman Club that Dexter and Charley have their sights on, an overarching plot structure that has given the last few episodes a procedural, kill-of-the week flavor. The newest episode is no exception, offering little in the way of focus regarding a central narrative and, instead, content to introduce and resolve a succinct story within a single episode.
While “Young Blood” benefits from its more streamlined and less wayward storytelling approach, the latest episode emphasizes just how starkly the new season has lacked a compelling hook. If one looks back at the history of Dexter, the best seasons have been grounded in a single premise, whether that be Dexter’s tug-of-war with Doakes in Season 2 or his exploration into the double life of the Trinity Killer in Season 4. Four episodes in and Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 continues to lack that kind of a compelling hook, a core and focused premise to draw viewers in and structure the season around.
But when taken as an isolated episode, “Young Blood” offer some interesting and intriguing moments for Dexter fans to feast on. The twist that the Jaw Splitter who shows up at the residence Charley and Dexter have rented is a young man, played by It and Shazam! star Jack Dylan Grazer no less, rather than the elderly serial killer the duo expected, works well and graces Dexter with its first Gen Z serial killer.
While the dialogue Grazer is tasked with delivering screams of a middle-aged man’s disgruntled, reductionistic perspective of Gen Z, JJ makes for a compelling addition to the series, in part due to the commitment of Grazer’s performance. The scene in which JJ discusses the first time he witnessed his father kill someone unsettles and mesmerizes in equal measure as Grazer’s eccentricities are toned down to give way to a more reflective and tormented version of the character.
JJ’s inclusion proves most captivating, however, in the parallels his character shares with the Morgans. As Dexter tries to determine if JJ fits the code or is more so a victim of an abusive father, he sees what kind of person Harrison could have become if he imposed his serial killing ways upon his son. It’s a fascinating thought experiment for Dexter, one that forces him to re-evaluate the morality and validity of his parenting in New Blood and Resurrection Season 1.
Upon uncovering JJ’s true depravity and subsequent killing him, Dexter’s arc is rounded out by an unexpected conversation with Harrison that finally lays the foundation for a novel, thought-provoking direction for the season to head in. Frustrated by the NYPD’s failure to apprehend both the Five Boroughs Killer and the New York Ripper, Harrison laments, “The serial killers are winning. You are the only person who can actually stop these monthwde. You’re necessary. I’ve changed my mind. You should take out the Ripper. And maybe I can help you again.”
These words spoken by Harrison would have delighted the Dexter of New Blood, who was desperate to make his son a companion for his serial killing exploits. But the Dexter here is more mature, hesitant, and, especially after his interactions with JJ, cognizant of the ways in which the sins of the father can spell trouble for the next generation. Despite Harry urging Dexter not to accept Harrison’s plea and keep the worlds of serial killing and parenting separate, Dexter hesitatingly nods, implying that his desire to have a partner who truly understands him may outweigh his concerns about such a decision’s implications.
Speaking of partners, Dexter’s potential romance with Charley seemingly comes to an abrupt end in the new episode. After dealing with JJ together, Dexter purchases wine with the hope that he has finally found someone who sees him and values him for who he is. Unfortunately for Dex, it seems Charley doesn’t feel the same way. Leaving to the airport with a proclamation that their work together is done, Charley seemingly shuts the door on any further bond with Dexter, which gives way to his desperation to forego logic and follow emotion in the forthcoming scene with Harrison’s offer to help him.
Elsewhere, both the FBK and NY Ripper storylines take a relative back seat in this episode. The latter is restricted to a single scene in which a deeply unsettling Brian Cox demonstrates just how twisted and menacing the NY Ripper is. FBK, meanwhile, remains frustratingly underdeveloped and almost entirely devoid of any characteristic that makes him stand apart from the array of other killers that have featured in Dexter over the years. Both of these characters hold immense promise for Resurrection, primarily due to the caliber of actor that Dan Stevens and Brian Cox belong to, but, with four episodes in, neither has lived up to their billing quite yet.
Then there’s Joey Quinn, whose role in the season remains puzzling to say the least. It’s obviously incredible to see Desmond Harrington back as the fan-favorite character, but Quinn’s interactions with Dexter continue to feel inconsistent with the more contentious relationships that characterized the two characters’ bond in the original series’ run. Perhaps more baffling is Quinn’s seeming total absence of suspicion toward Dexter, a man who two of Quinn’s former colleagues accused of being the Bay Harbor Butcher (conveniently right before both died under mysterious circumstances). Surely, the series is keeping Quinn’s true motivations and suspicions close vest as it would be unreasonable to think he doesn’t harbor suspicions of and ulterior motives for his old nemesis, although this has yet to be seen.
On a final note, the latest episode concludes on the definition of a cliffhanger, with Dexter opening the door of his apartment and announcing, “You’re alive?” to a figure unseen by the audience. It seems inevitable that the person he is speaking to is Mia LaPierre / Lady Vengeance, the serial killer played by Krysten Ritter, although how the series will explain how she survived the events of last season is certainly a head-scratcher.
VERDICT: 6/10
After a trio of unfocused episodes juggling a few too many plot threads and characters, Dexter: Resurrection‘s second season returns to a more streamlined and less wayward storytelling approach, offering some interesting and intriguing moments for Dexter fans to feast on. While the Jaw Splitter storyline gives the episode a procedural, kill-of-the-week flavor, the introduction of JJ, played by Jack Dylan Grazer, proves most captivating, particularly in the parallels his character shares with the Morgans and the thought-provoking questions he forces Dexter to confront about the morality and validity of his parenting. Harrison’s unexpected offer to help Dexter take out the New York Ripper finally lays the foundation for a novel direction for the season to head in, one that could explore the ways in which the sins of the father can spell trouble for the next generation. Elsewhere, the potential romance with Charley seemingly comes to an abrupt end, while both the Five Boroughs Killer and NY Ripper storylines remain frustratingly underdeveloped, and Quinn’s role in the season continues to feel puzzling and inconsistent. Four episodes in, Dexter: Resurrection Season 2 continues to lack a compelling hook or a core and focused premise to draw viewers in, but its final moments conclude on the definition of a cliffhanger, offering promise and intrigue for the story ahead.
The second season of Dexter: Resurrection premiered globally Friday, October 18 on Paramount+. New episodes of the ten-episode second season are available to stream weekly on Fridays, culminating in the season finale on Friday, January 1.